The Peter Allen Inn- Kinsman, OH

The Peter Allen Inn successfully provides an intimate lodging experience, without it ever feeling oppressive. With just three rooms, it could have gone either way. It truly is a delicate balance; a situation well known by travelers that are drawn to the architectural merits of historic residential properties, yet who also dread the traditional bed and breakfast experience of socializing with the hosts. In this case, the owners nailed it.

Built in 1820 by prominent architect Will Smith, the two story Federal structure with fan windows, dentil molding and decorative pilasters cost just $3000 to construct. Commissioned by Dr. Peter Allen, a surgeon who honed his skills during The War of 1812, the space functioned as both his residence and office until he relocated his practice to Oberlin, Ohio.

Sold to a local minister, the house remained relatively unchanged until 1903, when Dr. Allen’s grandson returned to the rural property and purchased the sitting room’s woodwork, in an early instance of architectural salvage. Under his ownership, the well traveled woodwork followed him to two Cleveland residences, adorning billiard room walls. The same woodwork was then returned to The Peter Allen house in the 1950s, as part of an early restoration project.

The guest rooms upstairs are spacious and well appointed, boasting beautifully updated marble baths. Downstairs, the inn’s cozy tavern looks as if it could be original, even though it isn’t. In warmer months, the lushly landscaped patio is available for both dining and drinks, both of which they do exceptionally well.

Indeed, the excellent onsite restaurant and tavern further elevate the experience, making it a worthy destination in an otherwise sleepy town. An all around excellent property, The Peter Allen Inn has many of the amenities of a larger hotel, with much more character.